Reviews

Based on 3624 reviews
83%
(2995)
6%
(204)
5%
(168)
2%
(83)
5%
(173)
Icelandic cod

great tasting cod. NY Steak and Seafood is my go to for
my seafood. Being landlocked now in beef and potato country
far my native NE roots, I look forward to receiving great seafood from them.

M
Veal Cutlets
Mary Lohse
Wonderful!

Finding veal in California is imposable. I knew I would have to order online so I found New York Steak Co. with a google search. My order came quickly and well packaged and still very cold.
I was suprised to find a free package of shrimp with my order.
The veal was tender and delicious!
Thank you New York Steak Co. for making my Mother-in-Laws birthday dinnner special.

M
Potato Crusted Cod
Marjorie LaBarbera
Fresh

These cod filets were delicious. Easy to prepare. Just heat and eat.
I will definitely buy again.

G
Filet of Sole
Granville Thompson

Great fish!

G
Stuffed Chicken Breasts
Granville Thompson
Chicken

The best!

Great Cordon Bleu

For many years, we enjoyed the Chicken Cordon Bleu from Schwan's. When we heard they were going out of business, we started searching for an alternative. We tried several brands from the local groceries but were not very good. We took a chance on these; they are fantastic. The portion size is slightly bigger than Schwans, and they taste even better.

Very good

Easy to pop in for dinner with hectic schedule

Gourmet seafood with two free lobster tails

As usual, the seafood is perfectly fresh and delicious. I'm going to have scallops and shrimp to last me a good long time. The four filet mignon look scrumptious. They are going to be Christmas dinner (along with the bacon-wrapped scallops) with some shrimp cocktail as an appetizer. Yummmmm.......

D
Stuffed Sole
Deanna McLellan
Fabulous

I just had one of the stuffed sole. I could have this every day of my life. The crab/scallop.breadcrumb stuffing is so good. I’m going to order this at least once a month.

D
Stuffed Sole
Deanna McLellan
Fabulous

I just had one of the stuffed sole. I could have this every day of my life. The crab/scallop.breadcrumb stuffing is so good. I’m going to order this at least once a month.

S
Jumbo Scallops
Susan Kocak
recieved on time jumbo scallops

I received on time the jumbo scallops I ordered. They look beautiful. Will be using them on Christmas Eve.

T
Lobster & Shrimp Cakes
Theodore VanNort, Jr.
Lobster and shrimp caked

I ordered the lobster and shrimp cakes. They were delicious with plenty of shrimp and lobster in each cake. I'll definitely be ordering these again.

Very good

They were tasty ,easy to prepare.

Excellent Quality!

I purchased a lot of Seafood online and I have never received an order so perfectly packaged!
The Lobster tails are perfect and all uniform in size. The pricing is the best out there and very competitive. Will definitely be purchasing again!

Excellent Quality!

I purchased a lot of Seafood online and I have never received an order so perfectly packaged!
The Lobster tails are perfect and all uniform in size. The pricing is the best out there and very competitive. Will definitely be purchasing again!

Delish!

The ribs were great.

J
Empanadas
Jorge Rodriguez
Insane!!

Hey Andrew these chicken empanadas are insane, hands down one of the best chicken emapanadas I’ve eaten and this is coming from a Dominican man who’s brought up eating empanadas from childhood, except we call them pastelitos. Great job. Thank you.

J
Empanadas
Jorge Rodriguez
Insane!!

Hey Andrew these chicken empanadas are insane, hands down one of the best chicken emapanadas I’ve eaten and this is coming from a Dominican man who’s brought up eating empanadas from childhood, except we call them pastelitos. Great job. Thank you.

Always amazing food and reliable shipping even in a snow storm!! Thank you

Excellent meatballs

Excellent meat ball tastes homemade

Fabulous

[****]

Excellent

B
Coconut Breaded Shrimp
Barb Trobaugh
Shrimp

We have enjoyed this shrimp every time we ordered it, always the best I’ve found! Highly recommend!

P
Veggie Burger
Patricia kelly
burger

First time having veggies burger.They are easy to make with a nice taste but Im old fashioned need my meat burger