Reviews

Based on 4184 reviews
82%
(3428)
6%
(242)
5%
(199)
3%
(106)
5%
(209)
Filet of sirloin

Out of this world good . I ordered more !

The quality is always good. I don’t always like the price but well worth it for these crab claws.

All products arrived fully frozen and I am located in the southwestern US.

Love the items purchased and fast delivery.

J
Bacon Wrapped Scallops
John Peterson
Bacon wrapped scallops

Great product I will definitely order them again

Great tast

Ty for your help dinggreat job for tasty products

p
Breaded Shrimp
penny king
breaded shrimp

Excellent shrimp, large & not too much breading.

C
Pork Dumplings
Carol Bobrowsky
Meaty, tender, would order again!!

These ribs are melt in your mouth tender, so easy to prepare! A bit too much sauce so I added orange marmalade and it made all the difference! My daughter, who hardly ever gets excited about taste of food , raved about these ribs and ate all the leftovers the nex t evening!!

Great Salmon

Absolutely delicious salmon and easy to prepare. You can taste the difference between wild caught and farm raised. I've ordered several times.

These are great crab legs. Always fresh and clean. I love them

N
Filet of Sole
NADINE CAFLISSCH
Filet of Sole

Received my first order (new customer): I inadvertently ordered between Xmas & New Years...didn't anticipate holiday staff regarding shipping delays. Sole arrived w/no dry ice, but still frozen solid. Nicely packaged, and size and quantity of filets are good for me (one person). Flavor didn't match what what "Dover Sole" used to taste like when I lived in Bay Area, CA, but still VERY good. I will order again. (Unable to find Sole in Pittsburgh, PA, area, so happy that I found this website/supplier.)

Wonderful service and products

I love NYSteak and Seafood. They have great steaks and their service is excellent. Andrew is always helpful and professional. I have worked with him for several years- Christmas orders for our clients.
Always takes great care of us.😊😊

F
Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Frank J Moschella
Bacon wrapped scallops

The scallops were awesome very easy to prepare, tasted great, cooked very evenly. I was dissapointed on one thing, I ordered 120 but the 4 packages only totaled to 109. I was shorted 11 scallops. Besides that they were great.

B
Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Barbara Considine
Christmas Eve Treat

Our Christmas Eve gathering was wonderful and what made it exceptional was our new treat, bacon wrapped scallops. The best we have ever served. Sweet tender and large. Great product. Thank You

Yum

The gift pack of steak and scallops were delicious

Very good

My grandsons favorite...easy to prepare and a life saver to have on hand for unexpected visits..

Very satisfied

The Filet was tender and flavorful. Loved the ribs. The sauce was delicious, and the ribs were so meaty and just feel off the bone.

R
Veal Cutlets
RON YOUNG
veal cutlets

the best veal i have had since i moved to florida 23 years ago. i will be sending a reorder very soon. it was awesome

Excellent!

Very high quality. Large and super fresh. I will order again.

Delicious

Very high quality and fresh! Excellent for chilled cocktail as well as heat and served over linguine with lemon butter sauce.

C
Stuffed Chicken Breasts
Caryn A. Wiggins
Chicken Kiev

Delicious! With overnight shipping, the poultry arrived frozen. Thanks so much!

P
Potato Crusted Cod
Patricia Blackwell

This is my third order of multiple packages of these delicious potato crusted cod. Cod doesn't swim around here in Florida and it's my favorite fish. The added potato just adds to the flavor. I have a special dish that the serving fits exactly. Just put the frozen filet in the dish on 375° for 35 minutes while you fix all the sides. Perfect fast, healthy, complete dinner for one in no time with no effort. Fits my lifestyle perfectly.

P
Cooked Shrimp
Patricia Blackwell
Prize Winner

Always wanted to provide a shrimp cocktail appetizer but never could find the right sized shrimp or figure out how long to cook or what, if any, flavoring. This order checks all the boxes. Just thaw, dry off and serve them up. They won the prize at my Christmas party...sooo easy.

Excellent

I have to say these were even better than I expected. We have been looking for a good source for Chicken. The grocery stores only seemed to have large tough chicken. I can tell you that we hit the jackpot with New York Steak Company! We have tried most of their chicken products and we have been very pleased with each one of them . I highly recommend their poultry products . The stuffed chicken is exceptional.

Best gift

Bought with seafood gift box ,just the perfect exta touch